Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich Recipe

Who doesn’t love a good ice cream cookie sandwich? This recipe is for the ultimate homemade ice cream cookie sandwich, made with rich and creamy ice cream sandwiched between two soft and chewy cookies. So simple to make and everyone will love them. These ice cream sandwiches make the perfect picnic treat. 

Love this recipe? Get daily updates on what’s new or a new recipe to try. Follow us on Instagram.

Homemade Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

When you are craving a delicious ice cream cookie sandwich, I’ve got the perfect recipe for you. This ice cream cookie sandwich is easy to make and absolutely delicious. All you need is some vanilla ice cream, cake mix chocolate chip cookies, and a few simple ingredients.

The best part of this recipe is that you can customize it however you want. Add your favorite flavors of ice cream, like mint chocolate chip, and cookies to create the perfect treat for yourself or your friends.

What do you call a cookie ice cream sandwich

If you have ever run out to the ice cream truck, you know what a Chipwich is. You can also find them at gas station ice cream freezers. A Chipwich ice cream cookie sandwich is 2 soft cookies that is filled with ice cream. Typically, it is a chocolate chip cookie and filled with vanilla ice cream. Sometimes, you will see a vanilla cookie that has the sprinkles along the ice cream. 

More Amazing Cookie Recipes

• The Best Copycat Mickey Mouse Pie Crust Cookies
• Unicorn Cake Mix Cookies
• Lemon Cake Mix Cookies
• Rolo Cookies with Cake Mix

Why you need soft cookies for an ice cream sandwich 

You want to make sure the cookies you use for the ice cream sandwich is soft because otherwise the cookies can be too hard to eat. A crispy cookie that is frozen is going to feel like a teeth breaker. A soft cookie, even when it is frozen, is still easy to bite into.

What is the cookie of an ice cream sandwich made of?

I always use my cake mix cookies. I take the basic recipe and add either chocolate chips or M&Ms. You can also use other cookie flavors. I love the cake mix peanut butter cookies as well.  The most important thing about this ice cream cookie sandwich is that you are using a soft and chewy cookie.

How to store ice cream sandwiches

You can store your ice cream cookie sandwiches in the freezer for up to 2 weeks. First, I freeze my Chipwich on a baking sheet or a plate. This lets the ice cream cookie sandwich freeze into place so it does not stick to the plastic. Then, I like to wrap each ice cream cookie sandwich with plastic wrap and put in a plastic baggie so that they don’t get freezer burned. When you are ready to eat one, let it sit out on the counter for about 5 minutes so that it is soft enough to bite into. 

Do I have to Make Homemade Cookies

I prefer to make homemade cookies. Especially cake mix cookies because they are fast and simple. However, you do not have to use homemade cookies. You can use store bought cookies if you are in a hurry or don’t want to use the oven. 

Tips for Making Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

Making the cookies a bit special. Because there is so much sweet with these ice cream cookie sandwiches, I like to add a little bit of salt to the tops of the cookies. 

Freeze the cookies. When you are making this ice cream cookie recipe you want to freeze the cookies before you add the ice cream. I like to make the cookies the day before and about 30 minutes before it is time to make the cookies, I like to freeze the cookies. It makes it easier to work with. 

Good Quality Ice Cream. While I love making homemade low calorie ice cream, for this recipe, you want a good ice cream. Homemade no churn ice doesn’t work that well because it tends to melt faster. 

Rolling the cookies. When you roll the ice cream cookie sandwiches, the cookies look so pretty. Not only that, it gives the cookies another level of yumminess. You can use a wide variety of things to roll the cookies in. You can use sprinkles or mini chocolate chip cookies. I even like to use very thin almond slices. Dip the filled cookies in the mixture and coat the ice cream well.

Can I skip the sprinkles? You don’t need to roll the ice cream cookie sandwiches in the sprinkles or anything else. If won’t affect the sandwiches in anyway. 

Do I need anything special to make the cookie ice cream sandwiches? You don’t need anything special for the ice cream sandwiches. I like to use an ice cream scoop to add the ice cream to the cookies, but in a pinch, you can use a rubber spatula, wooden spoon or tablespoons. 

Love Recipes? Join our Facebook Group, The Best Must Try Recipes, Easy Delicious Recipes for Everyone

Ingredients

Get the full list of ingredients, with measurements, and step-by-step instructions at the bottom of the post in the printable recipe card.

• Half Gallon Vanilla Ice Cream
• 16 Cake Mix Cookie– While making the cookies, add in whatever you want. I am using M&Ms. 
• Topping– I like to use things like Mini chocolate chips, Coconut flakes, Sliced almonds, Walnut pieces, Sprinkles

How to Make Ice Cream Cookie Sandwiches

Make the cake mix cookies according to the directions, add in whatever add ins you want before baking. 

30 minutes before assembling the cookie, freeze the cookies.

Add the toppings in a separate bowl or plates for each one. 

Place a cookie upside down, with the top on the table and add a scoop of ice cream on it. 

Place another cookie on top, right side up, pressing it down lightly. 

Clean the ice cream that has come out from sides of the cookies.

Roll the sandwich into the toppings that you choose. If the toppings do not stick well, press it in with your hand. 

Place the finished sandwich on a cookie sheet, pan or plate covered with a piece of parchment paper.

Put in the freezer for 10-20 minutes to harden.

Store in a freezer bag.

When you are ready to have one, place it on a plate at room temperature for a few minutes before eating, as the cookies will be hard.